Loader Icon
live aman bg

Differences Between Insurance Agents and Brokers: Roles, Advantages, and Disadvantages

Differences Between Insurance Agents and Brokers: Roles, Advantages, and Disadvantages
  • 26 Sep 2023
  • Redaksi Liveaman
  • Mins

Insurance agents and brokers are two crucial entities in the insurance industry that are often used interchangeably. However, they have significant differences in how they operate, their roles in assisting clients, and how they relate to insurance policies. In this article, we will delve into the differences between insurance agents and brokers, as well as discuss the pros and cons of each role. Additionally, we will explain when it is advisable to use an agent or broker in the context of insurance.

Roles of Insurance Agents and Brokers

Role of Insurance Agents:
Insurance agents are individuals or entities working for a specific insurance company. They have contractual relationships with one or more insurance companies and are responsible for promoting, selling, and managing insurance policies from these companies. Agents often possess in-depth knowledge of the insurance products offered by the companies they work for.

The primary advantage of insurance agents is their comprehensive knowledge of the insurance products they offer. They typically receive ongoing training from insurance companies to understand these products thoroughly. This enables them to provide more detailed advice to their clients, helping them understand the benefits and risks associated with the policies they are considering.

Furthermore, insurance agents can provide better support to policyholders regarding claims. They have direct access to the insurance companies they represent, allowing them to expedite the claims process and assist policyholders in resolving any issues that may arise.

Role of Insurance Brokers:
Insurance brokers are entities that work on behalf of clients or policyholders. They do not have exclusive affiliations with specific insurance companies. Instead, they act as intermediaries between clients and insurance companies. Brokers are tasked with seeking the best offers for their clients from various insurance companies. They offer independent advice and ensure the best interests of their clients are prioritized.

One of the main advantages of using insurance brokers is the broader access to various insurance products. Brokers are not tied to a particular insurance company, so they can search for offers from multiple companies and compare them to find the most suitable product for the client.
Brokers also provide independent advice, meaning they do not have biases towards products from specific insurance companies. They are accountable to their clients and strive to ensure that clients get the best protection at competitive prices.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Insurance Agents:

Advantages of Insurance Agents:

  1. In-Depth Knowledge: Agents have a deep understanding of the insurance products from the companies they work for. They can provide detailed explanations of the features and benefits of each product.
  2. Policy Support: They can offer assistance with claims and policy-related issues to policyholders. Their direct relationship with insurance companies allows them to facilitate the claims process more efficiently.
  3. Connections with Insurance Companies: Agents have direct access to the insurance companies they represent. This can be helpful in resolving issues or answering questions during the coverage period.

Disadvantages of Insurance Agents:

  1. Limited Choices: Agents are limited to products from the companies they work for, which may restrict options for clients. If the insurance company does not offer a product that suits the client’s needs, the agent may not have other alternatives to offer.
  2. Bias Toward Interests: Agents have an obligation to the insurance company that employs them. This can influence their recommendations, as they may be more inclined to promote products from their company over products from others that might be a better fit for the client.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Insurance Brokers:

Advantages of Insurance Brokers:

  1. Wider Selection: Brokers can offer choices from various insurance companies, allowing clients access to a variety of products. This enables clients to compare multiple options and select the one that suits them best.
  2. Independent Advice: Brokers aim to serve their clients’ interests objectively without biases towards products from specific insurance companies. They provide independent guidance on the most suitable products for clients.
  3. Price Negotiation: Brokers have the ability to negotiate with insurance companies to secure better prices for their clients. They can seek discounts or special offers that may not be available when dealing directly with an insurance company.

Disadvantages of Insurance Brokers:

  1. Brokerage Fees: Using an insurance broker may result in additional fees. Brokers typically receive commissions or service charges from their clients, which can make insurance more expensive compared to purchasing directly from an insurance company.
  2. Limited Knowledge: Brokers may not have in-depth knowledge of products from every insurance company. This can result in clients not receiving very detailed explanations of the products offered.

Also read: Insurance Agents: Roles, Benefits, and Drawbacks

When to Use an Insurance Agent or Broker

When to use an agent or broker in the context of insurance depends on your personal preferences, the complexity of your insurance needs, and how much time you have to evaluate options.

If you desire in-depth advice and have limited time, insurance agents may be more suitable. They can help you better understand the products offered by the company they work for and provide support regarding claims.

On the other hand, if you want access to a wide range of options and seek independent advice, insurance brokers are a good choice. They can help you compare products from various insurance companies and ensure you get the best protection at a competitive price.


The key difference between insurance agents and brokers lies in their affiliations with insurance companies and their roles in assisting clients. Understanding these differences can help you make a better decision when choosing an insurance assistance source that aligns with your needs. Therefore, consider your options carefully before deciding whether to use an insurance agent or broker in your insurance journey. With a better understanding of both roles, you can make a wise decision and secure insurance coverage that suits your needs.

Aman is a company that offers various health protection products for employees. By having reliable employee insurance like Aman, the company can provide essential benefits to its employees. In the long run, this can improve employee satisfaction, productivity, and retention. When it comes to employee health benefits, Aman is the right choice to assist companies and employees in meeting their health protection needs, register now!

Contact Us
Your Name*
Phone Number*
Work Email* (Please don’t use public email such as gmail, yahoo, hotmail, etc)
Company Name*
Confirmation email has been sent. Please wait our respond within 24 hours.
We have send the OTP to your email. Please verify.
Edit work email
Mohon masukkan kode verifikasi (OTP) disini*
Didn’t receive the verification code?120
We have send the OTP to your email. Please verify.
Please enter the correct OTP